AI & Agents

Referee.chat

Last updated 2026-08-15 · benchmark measured 2026-09-16 — deterministic & reproducible

Referee.chat runs multi-model AI panels to argue a goal until a referee rules it done.

Are you the maker of Referee.chat? Claim this listing. It is free, takes a meta tag, a DNS record or GitHub admin rights, and never changes the score.

Launched something? Add your product, free.

To cite this score: legit.show/s/referee-chat/2026-09-16. That address never changes; this page moves with every re-measure.

Legit.Show scored Referee.chat 90/100 on 2026-09-16, measured across 6 of 7 frames from its public surface. legit.show/s/referee-chat/2026-09-16

Is Referee.chat production-ready?

Legit.Show scores Referee.chat 90 out of 100 — the simple average of its 6 measured frames. Legit.Show ran its deterministic 7-Frame production-readiness benchmark on Referee.chat (public-surface assessment), measured from the public surface with no LLM in the scoring path. Its strongest frame is Privacy; its weakest is Security. 6 of the seven frames returned a score; Accessibility was not measurable on this service and is recorded as null — not as zero. Every frame it averages is published with its evidence on the Legit.Show listing.

The 7 Frames

• Performance — 80/100
• Accessibility — not measurable on this service (null — not scored as 0)
• Security — 60/100
  How this compares across the catalogue: The Web Security Baseline
• Privacy — 100/100
  How this compares across the catalogue: The Privacy Gap
• Reliability — 100/100
• Standards — 100/100
• Discoverability — 100/100

What we measured

• Security headers present: X-Frame-Options, X-Content-Type-Options, Referrer-Policy.
• No Content-Security-Policy and no HSTS.
• Served over HTTPS with a valid certificate.
• Real Lighthouse performance run — 567 ms to first byte.
• Returns a proper 404 for unknown routes.
• 3 of 3 sampled routes reachable.
• Has a reachable privacy policy.
• Sets cookies / loads scripts with no consent prompt.

Who it's for

Researchers · Decision-makers · Mathematicians · Content creators · Professionals seeking evidence-based answers

Pricing

Free tier with $1 starting credit; paid credit from $10 top-up (never expires); charged per-token usage by model; 5% infrastructure fee on BYOK after first $5; unused credit refundable

Sources and updates

Description

Taken from referee.chat's own website on 2026-08-15.

Operator

Muddy Holdings LLC, as named in referee.chat's terms, privacy page or footer.

Benchmark

Measured by Legit.Show from the live site, the way any visitor sees it — with no access to its code or accounts. Same method for every product, and no AI decides the score. Last checked 2026-09-16.

Put together from public information, without Referee.chat's involvement. If anything here is wrong, tell us and a person will check it.

Visit Referee.chat → · Alternatives to Referee.chat → · How this was measured →